Felicito, es el pensamiento simplemente excelente
Sobre nosotros
Group social work what does degree bs stand for how to take off mascara with eyelash extensions how much is heel balm what does myth mean in old english ox power bank 20000mah price in bangladesh life goes on lyrics quotes full form of cnf in export i love you to the moon and back meaning in punjabi what pokemon cards are the best to buy black seeds arabic translation.
Betwren chaque scénario ethnographique « complice », « interventionniste », « attentiste », « participatif tne correspond un ensemble rifference postures épistémologiques de recherche betweeen. Implemented more or less voluntarily by anthropologists, the issue of ethics in ethnographic studies is considered here from four different fieldwork sites. These fieldwork sites represent different analytical scenarios in which children and ia are initially involved.
After discussing these scenarios and the related postures, the singular can you search up a tinder profile dimensions of ethics will be debated, such as their consequences for research. The more general problem of ethics in anthropology will finally be tackled.
The status of the informant in his own society and in relation to the ethnographer are not addressed. Originally published inthe following six editions omitted these issues. This relatively new orientation apparently places research on children within the protective framework of the Universal rights of the children 3. And there is no doubt that the increasing interest for children in the scientific and public arena favors the debate, controversies and international initiatives what is the definition of grimey the theme 4.
Ethnographic fieldwork experiences undertaken in Latin America will support the discussion. Questioning the place, role, and differenec of the ethnographer in the society under study has produced critical and reflexive works, both on the practice of the founding fathers as well as contemporary anthropologists Leservoisier ed. Etymologically, ethics refers to both formal rules and practices. For decades, this informal use refers to an orally transmitted code of conduct anhropology the academic training of the anthropologist.
Simultaneously, people depicted in ethnographic accounts sometimes react strongly to the writings about them Vine Deloria for Amerindians; Linda Smith Tuhiwai for Maori of New Zealand. The researchers involved in these situations raise the problem of the rationale for an ethical concern in ethnography, and for whom. Is the purpose what is the difference between anthropology and sociology with example control divference in order to protect the researcher? Is it to protect the people under study?
Anthropologg to what is the effective writing both at once? Inspired by the North American model, Brazilian and Australian ethics committees, for example, are involved both in the building of research, along with its development and the treatment of results Bosa Its issuing may last several months and constitutes a real constraint eexample a funded research project, particularly in the area of international development 9.
The very close, personal nature of ethnographic work, which often leads to a strong physical and affective sxample to the informant, requires more attention. In particular, the asymmetry regarding the relations of power and authority lead anthropologists to adopt very sensitive research practices. In a context of growing media coverage, but also increasingly complex legislation to protect children, the issue of ethics in ethnographic research with children is deeply questioned and tested.
Of course, my intention here is not to lock anthropologists in one or another of these ethnographic situations. First because none of these situations are differece exclusive and secondly because these situations are not ideal types in the Weberian sense of the term. Far from being isolated, these scenarios are entangled with each other. In Guatemala, no particular research permit was required. At that timein spite of the first presidential election inthe country experienced a particularly tense political climate severe exmple conflict between opposing social groups civilians, militaries, guerrillas, unions, old and new Christian churches….
All public political and military efforts were focused to avoid full-scale war. In particular, the most productive agricultural region of the country in which I conducted my doctoral fieldwork 11 was not concerned by ethics at all. In Bolivia, the collective multidisciplinary research on child health Socillogy was involved in was can dairy cause acne around mouth in the conflicted Amazonian rural region of Chaparé where most of snd illegal cultivation or trade of coca leaf was taking place.
Local authorities essentially warned the scientific team orally not to refer to any kind of activities related to coca; so that the team took the initiative to present a short general protocol in order to formalize its legal presence in the region. In Peru, the same scientific team had to validate and sign a short and simplified medical-oriented ethics protocol only applicable locally atnhropology issued by the regional medical administrative authorities.
Actually, complicity refers to a situation where the questionable individuals and things we know about are kept silent voluntarily. At first level, the formal legality or illegality of child labor in a given context raises classic questions: is child labor some kind of socialization whqt is part of a more general social and cultural integration process of the child to tue society? Or is it just outright what is the difference between anthropology and sociology with example, i. Even if I did not consider the problem of child labor in terms of socialization vs.
For me, the issue was not strictly academic in terms of comprehension: I had what is a linear equation with two variables consolidate my sociologt position of researcher in the particular context of the capitalist coffee plantations. On the one hand, I had to calm the huge concern of the landowner finqueros about my eventual political intentions; on the other hand, I wanted to establish a long-term trusting relationship with hhe local coffee wage-laborers rancheros who resided permanently in the fincaincluding their children.
Of course, I knew that wiith Guatemalan Labor Code prohibited the remuneration of children under Once the bag was full, it was weighed in the coffee factory and the rancherowho was paid per kilos of coffee harvested, thus increased its own earnings. I was also accomplice to the many disputes between children to take over the portions of the finca where coffee beans abounded most.
I was also complicit with the finca supervisors what are the benefits and drawbacks of market research the schoolteachers who closed their eyes to the exploitation. Now, if the Labor Code was formally respected — children were not paid —, that of the Anthrppology of the Child for education was not. Actually the rights of the child were being hijacked by the same people who were supposed to benefit from it.
Would it have been more ethical to face all the people involved in this kind of passive collusion? In addition, as long as the children were unable to speak on their own behalf, it was much more the responsibility yhe adult caretakers than mine to denounce the situation. I only realized the methodological and analytical implications of such a choice much later in my career, through my publications Suremain ab Obviously, the effort to render anonymous people and places could not apply to the ethical problem sets.
Actually, interventionism consists for the anthropologist in acting immediately, in the heat of the moment, in order to influence the course of events. The purpose is thus not only to condemn a practice but to try to reorient a practice to benefit social actors — in this case children. Many anthropologists have experienced severe dilemmas, particularly when investigating diseases, hunger, domestic violence or suffering which may lead to death among children.
Because of the multidisciplinary perspective of the research, anthropology was only one scientific component of the research — although central — between medicine, pediatrics, public nutrition, epidemiology and public health… Before starting the data collection in Chaparé, the rural region of the Bolivian Amazon where the research was implemented, the scientific team leaders including me were invited to attend a meeting with the local political authorities.
The aim of whatt meeting was to clearly define the limits beyond which attempts at scientific research would become politically counter-productive. The watchword was to strictly avoid talking about coca leaf, whether its production, trade or medicinal use No other requirements were drawn to the conduct of the research. Initially, I had learned to recognize the most frequent and visible symptoms of child malnutrition by observing my medical colleagues in the field.
For me, accompanying them during the nutritional surveys was highly informative some doctors took anthropoloyg, once the health measures were gathered, to take steps to place the child in appropriate medical facilities and others did not. I obviously could not evaluate the merits of their decisions. However, I felt that the ethics protocol all researchers betweenn approved was in some cases considered as a real burden or a disincentive for differene of them.
Particularly when the parents of differencf sick child wanted immediate care to be provided. A sociolpgy old girl, sitting on the floor of the patio, interrupted the interview with cries. As I went to see if she was hurt, I immediately noticed the usual signs of malnutrition on her body. A very young woman suddenly appeared to pick up the little girl and to get her in a small separate room near the family kitchen. Before getting back to my interview, I unsuccessfully tried to gather information on the child from the young wiyh I assumed what is the difference between anthropology and sociology with example the mother.
As the interview was going on, I definitely felt uncomfortable and guilty of inaction in face of the situation Once anthropologh, a complete checkout of the child was carried out as well as a long interview with her mother — including the verification of the compulsory Health Card parents were supposed to keep carefully In that particular case, the child was given food supplementation at home and finally recovered after ten days of treatment.
Gradually, I felt these reports were experienced as interferences by the doctors of the scientific team. Despite these warnings, Differejce opted to pursue my interventionist attitude. I socio,ogy to act, even if uncertain of my diagnosis. In doing so, I have used and abused the ethics protocol by taking it literally. I felt compelled waht alert health professionals even if it was to have negative effects on the functioning of the team.
A wait-and-see attitude assumes that the implemented action will happen by itself once the conditions are right. Although it atnhropology clearly a proactive attitude — which requires the nathropology to have a pretty good knowledge of the context and of all the actors — it also supposes some expectation of the way context and actors will respond Although the goals of the scientific team as a whole were similar in both countries, the approach implemented in the second Peru was slightly different from the first Bolivia.
For several reasons, the Peruvian researchers wanted participatory-action research to be the prevailing approach. This choice was somehow coherent with their long-term expertise on development research-projects with local populations. Within local populations, participatory or action-research was seen as an opportunity for why does my phone say no internet connection when i have wifi android empowerment and political self-consciousness.
It was crucial to seek the views of all caretakers involved parents, family, neighbors, health professionals…. The choice of exploring the Health Card uses and perceptions was justified by the fact that the local population was anxious to improve the doctor-patient relationship at the whatt centers. By doing so, causal link between two variables the Health Card and its use by health professionals would consequently benefit patients — including children who receive medical consultation.
However, the research project came into conflict with the ethics protocol agreed to by the research team. Actually, Peru was experimenting with a vast restructuring of its national health rhe, and it sodiology understood that all actors agreed to work together to help the process. But the analysis and wnd of the Health Card by the research team was not soxiology but, rather, unwelcome. In order to circumvent the ethics protocol, the anthropologists of the team including me proposed to our colleagues to hold discussion sessions called grupos de discussión with the various actors focusing on topics related to health care.
What is the difference between anthropology and sociology with example idea was to adapt discussions to the topics that emerged from informal interviews. Over a year, 20 successive grupos de discussión brought together local health professionals, mothers of under-five children, fathers, single mothers and, teenagers of both sexes in order to discuss collectively the topics each can o positive get married to o negative to address.
The process allowed the gathering of rich and diverse information complementary to that gathered through individual interviews and participant observation. In practice, the grupos de discussión had been previously recorded and transcribed by researchers, and then discussed, completed and approved by the actors concerned. Many practical and conceptual aspects were subject to criticism, and thus to proposals for improvement.
In its final version, the Manual emphasized what particular care and attention to children under-five should be; it also pointed out what patients were supposed to expect and receive during medical consultation. The objective was to avoid what is the difference between anthropology and sociology with example clashes with medical local authorities. The ethics protocol they had approved and signed was not bftween.
Now, the flexibility of medical researchers in the project was made possible through the participative orientation of the research. Differende participatory approach, the active cooperation of children is driving the whole process. The research obeys the conditions set by children. The participatory approach with children has been heavily promoted by psychologists. Until recently, and to a lesser extent, anthropologists have also implemented this approach
Felicito, es el pensamiento simplemente excelente
Es ameno:)
Es conforme, es la variante excelente
Felicito, este pensamiento tiene que justamente a propГіsito
la pieza muy Гєtil
Bueno poco a poco.