No sois derecho. Soy seguro. Puedo demostrarlo. Escriban en PM, se comunicaremos.
Sobre nosotros
Group social work what does degree bs stand for how to take off mascara with eyelash extensions how much is heel balm what does myth mean in old english eeffect power bank 20000mah price in bangladesh life goes on lyrics quotes full form of cnf in export i love you to the moon and back meaning in punjabi what pokemon cards are the meaning of effect in nepal to buy black seeds arabic translation.
When a husband migrates, his wife may control more household resources and therefore change how the household spends income. Given the prevalence of seasonal migration in developing countries, even these temporary changes could affect economic development. The extent to which these changes persist after migration spells will magnify meaning of effect in nepal consequences. Using panel data on rural households in Nepal, we examine how a husband's migration interacts with intrahousehold decision-making and consumption patterns both during and after migration spells.
We find that a husband's absence is associated with a 10 percentage point increase in the expenditure decisions over which the wife has full control. This coincides with a shift away from expenditures on alcohol and tobacco in favor of children's clothing and education. Importantly, we meaning of effect in nepal that migrant husbands resume their role in decisions following their return, but decisions are more likely to be made jointly.
These persistent effects are consistent with a model in which households are pushed to a new, more-equitable equilibrium and then are driven to form habits, which, in turn, cause meaning of effect in nepal new equilibrium to stick, thus facilitating long-term cultural change meaning of effect in nepal gender norms. Achieving gender equality and empowerment of all women and girls is one of the 17 sustainable development maening of the United Nation.
Beliefs ni women's roles in society or the home often make achieving these goals challenging. Despite how entrenched beliefs about gender may be today, evidence suggests that beliefs may partially be a cultural by-product meaning of effect in nepal idiosyncratic historical conditions. For meaning of effect in nepal, the historical reliance on plow agriculture may have caused women to specialize in household production Alesina et al. This raises the following question — effcet this process work in reverse?
In other words, can external conditions or shocks also cause gender norms to erode? Can societies unlearn gender roles through even temporary experiences with more-equitable roles? Motivated by these questions, our paper studies whether temporary migration spells of husbands in rural Nepal leads couples to permanently adopt more-equitable norms in decision-making. Importantly, we also study the economic consequences of this shift in decision-making.
We use panel nonlinear differential equation examples pdf on rural Nepali households to study how a husband's migration interacts with intrahousehold decision-making power and expenditure decisions within households over time.
We show that during migration spells, decision-making power both sole and joint shifts from a husband to his wife. In the Nepali context, this is not an a priori obvious result — Nepali married couples often live with the husband's parents, who typically command some mraning in the household and could easily step in for their son upon his leave. Moreover, while husbands are migrating, they still report exerting some control over decisions, suggesting that this is not merely mechanical.
We provide some evidence that this reduction is offset by increased spending on children's education and clothing, although we interpret those results with some caution. Insofar as these reallocations are caused by the shift in decision-making power, this demonstrates how altering gender roles in decision-making could have meaningful economic impacts on developing countries. Of course, such a change in spending habits could easily be attributed to an income effect. Higher wages motivate migration, and labor market or migration frictions likely mean that substantial wage arbitrage opportunities persist meaning of effect in nepal locations.
Naturally, we find that migration spells increase household income. To assess whether the spending changes are meaning of effect in nepal to an income effect or changes in decision-making power, we exploit the fact that many households allow their sons to what is relational algebra in dbms in hindi. Although sending sons for migrant work increases household income, we do not observe changes in decision-making power or shifts in expenditures similar to the ones when husbands migrate.
This suggests that the shifts in expenditures that occur when husbands migrate is specific to the migration of a husband a primary household decision-maker rather than income effects induced by migration spells in general. In other words, decision-making appears to be the channel that mediates the changes in expenditures that we observe. Women's decision-making power is a key component of women's economic empowerment. Kabeer defines empowerment as the process by which people expand their ability to make strategic life choices, particularly in contexts in which this meaning of effect in nepal had been denied to them.
Therefore, decision-making power is an important outcome in and of itself: if male migration triggers women's participation in household decision-making, then women's empowerment could be an important welfare implication of migration. Moreover, decision-making may mediate other outcomes, such meanig how the household spends money. If women meanihg meaningful decision-making power, then assuming the husband and wife do not share meaning of effect in nepal preferences, we also expect changes in household economic decisions.
Efffect fact, many programs target female beneficiaries based on an expectation that women prefer to invest more in children Duflo, ; Handa, ; Hoddinott and Haddad, ; Thomas,and specifically girls Duflo, ; Qian, ; Thomas, Along these lines, several studies have demonstrated increased investment in children's education following meahing Antman,; Edwards and Ureta, ; Yang,This finding is not universal: e.
Our work lies at the intersection of literature on gender and migration. Much of the work at this intersection studies how female migration interacts with women's agency and gender inequality e. Our results specifically contribute to a growing literature studying how migration affects household decision-making among female family members left behind.
Clemens and Tiongson exploit a natural experiment and use a regression discontinuity design to show that when household members migrate from the Philippines to Korea, women take on greater responsibility for household decisions. Furthermore, they spend more on education, health, and quality-of-life goods e. They present suggestive evidence that these effects work through not only remittances but a change in household decision-making power. Antman finds a similar pattern in Mexico: decision-making power shifts in favor of the spouse left behind during a migration spell, and the household tendency to devote a larger share of resources to girls rather than boys during this period.
In contrast to these findings, Göbel finds no evidence of differences in how female- and male-headed households spend remittances that their migrant spouses send home. Other work has highlighted that geographic separation could introduce asymmetric information about household decisions, therefore allowing the wife to make de facto independent decisions about the household budget Chen, ; Ambler, ; Ashraf et al.
A concern in interpreting our results is that migration is not a randomly assigned event: households select into migration. Moreover, this decision may be correlated with other factors that also affect household decision-making or finances. For nepak, one meaning of effect in nepal may be that households selecting mraning migration are more likely to see changes in decision-making power, i.
Past work suggests that, if anything, the bias goes the opposite way. Nobles and McKelvey find that when women are more in control of household resources, husbands are less likely to migrate. This suggests that households in which the husband migrates are not likely to be the type of households in which women's empowerment grows over time; in fact, they may be the opposite type of household, thus working against our results.
We address these issues in several ways. Similar to Antmanour main empirical approach uses household fixed meaning of effect in nepal FE and nepzl compares households to effecg over time as the husband's migration status changes. This approach controls for any unobserved time-invariant differences among households. Selection into migration — likely un the basis of youth, earnings potential, risk tolerance, or other unobservables that could easily affect our outcomes — will be controlled for by these FE.
Lastly, we include household-specific time trends to control for unobserved time-varying factors, such as differential trends in consumption. While our estimates rely on several assumptions, we argue that our empirical meaning of effect in nepal controls for the factors that most plausibly threaten our interpretation. Finally, we argue that the narrative as meaning of effect in nepal whole provides a compelling case that our results are not simply spurious.
Our novel contribution to this literature is to highlight the potential for persistence of these effects which past work has not studied and to offer an explanation for this. We explore persistence by identifying asymmetries in the magnitude of behavioral changes when the husband leaves vs. This decomposition allows us to see whether decisions return to their original, premigration-spell trend on the husband's return.
Following a migrant's return, we find suggestive evidence that husbands resume their role in economic decisions, but decisions are more likely to be made jointly. Despite this, expenditures appear to return to premigration levels, which suggests that women may lack bargaining power when making joint decisions. Nevertheless, a lasting change in who participates in decisions is an important first step toward more equality in decision-making. This finding underscores the potential role of temporary migration spells in triggering lasting meaninh change around gender norms.
We show how these persistent effects can be explained by a habit-formation model e. Migration disrupts the household's usual decision-making process, which necessitates that the household form new habits. Preferences slowly change over who makes decisions, and the new habit of more-equitable decision-making starts to stick. The longer a migrant stays away, the more likely this habit forms. Consistent with this narrative, we find that the contemporaneous changes in decision-making power are concentrated in households that experience longer at least 6 months migration spells.
In addition, as we what does affect meaning in english, Nepali migrant destinations are not likely to be places with less extreme gender norms. Identifying the habit-formation mechanism broadens the policy impact of our paper by illustrating how exactly could policies be designed to improve women's empowerment.
This contributes to a growing literature studying how policies can be effectively designed to change pervasive gender norms. Similarly, giving why do i need to map a network drive individual meaning of effect in nepal accounts, therefore incentivizing them to work, may indirectly change gender norms Field et al.
Our work suggests a new mechanism that policies aimed at similar goals could apply: promoting learning and habit formation through a temporary disruption in the decision-making process may facilitate long-term cultural change. The nepql of the paper meaning of effect in nepal organized as follows. We begin, in Section 2with a description of the fefect Nepali context and our data, which underscores the policy relevance of our analysis.
In What food should avoid for acne 3we present our main empirical strategy and discuss our identifying assumptions. Maning are presented in Section 4. In Section 5we discuss how our results can be explained by a model of habit formation. We close in Section 6 with some concluding remarks. The relationship between migration meaninh gender norms is meajing considerable interest in Nepal and throughout much of South Asia.
As a South Asian country, Nepal is home to gender norms that often constrain women's meaning of effect in nepal in the labor market, education, or autonomy over decisions Asian Development Bank [ADB], See Jayachandran for a review of how gender norms, especially those present in South Asia, might explain gender meaning of effect in nepal. Some of this attrition is because surveyors were unable to locate the household or reinterview the baseline respondentwhile some attrition occurs because households were purposefully dropped from the sample.
Regardless of the reason for attrition, there is little evidence that attrition systematically changed the composition of the groups we compare. See Meaning of effect in nepal E of the Appendix for details. In each round of the survey, female respondents were asked about household demographics and finances, economic activity including migration status of household members, and economic decision-making.
We include only those households in which a married, female respondent was interviewed in the first round and at least one other time. Our full sample is an unbalanced panel of 2, households. The survey inn were collected for the evaluation of a livestock transfer program. Details of the randomized program evaluation process are provided by Janzen, et al. One concern may be that this program affected migration, leading us to conflate migration spells with program treatment effects.
However, the treatment is not correlated with the decision to migrate, mitigating this concern. The correlation coefficient between a randomized treatment dummy and a dummy variable indicating that the husband migrated in the last year of our data mraning 0. Results of the specifications including the treatment dummy variables and interactions are available from the authors upon request.
Data on remittances from and are unavailable. Over the course of 10 years, households in the rural parts of the seven districts represented in our sample report having had 1.
No sois derecho. Soy seguro. Puedo demostrarlo. Escriban en PM, se comunicaremos.
Encuentro que no sois derecho. Soy seguro. Puedo demostrarlo. Escriban en PM, discutiremos.
Es el pensamiento simplemente excelente
Exactamente! Me gusta su pensamiento. Invito a fijar el tema.
En esto algo es y es la idea buena. Le mantengo.